Scott Olson / Getty Images
A federal judge has blocked labor requirements for Medicaid patients in Kentucky, just days before the new rules put into effect by Governor Matt Bevin's government should come into force.
On Friday, US District Judge James Boasberg called the Trump approval of the program by the government, Kentucky HEALTH, "arbitrary and moody."
He writes that Minister of Health Alex Azar, when approving Kentucky's work request proposal, never adequately considered whether Kentucky HEALTH would actually help the state provide medicine to its citizens, a key target of Medicaid.
The judge pointed out that Azar did not mention that 95,000 people could lose cover under the plan – a custody he called "glaring."
A number of health policy experts praised the decision they made Described as "devastating" and "wild."
"The court made the right decision," says Elizabeth Lower-Basch, director of income and labor support at the Center for Law and Social Policy. "It noted that HHS was not Once considering the fundamental issue of whether the waiver would affect the central Medicaid goal of health care, Kentucky does not allow it to be implemented until HHS makes such an assessment. "
Gov. Bevin filed a counterclaim in February has threatened to dismantle Kentucky's Medicaid extension if the courts do not allow him to add the work requirements.
HHS has approved Gov. Bevin's request to change Kentucky's Medicaid program in January. It requires "ineligible" Medicaid recipients to either find work, undergo training, or volunteer to qualify for medical benefits. It was the first state to receive such approval after Seema Verma, the manager of the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services, said she would see such proposals positively.
Verma said in a statement that she was disappointed with the decision. 19659008] "The states are the laboratories of democracy and many administrations have been looking for them to develop and test reforms that have driven the objectives of the Medicaid program, and the Trump administration is no different."
She said the agency speaks with The Justice Department decided to appeal
Under Bevin's predecessor, Governor Steven Beshear, the state had extended Medicaid eligibility to more than 500,000 low-income residents. The Affordable Care Act allowed states to extend Medicaid benefits reserved for the disabled and parent of small children to low-income adults without children.
Verma and Azar have argued that Medicaid beneficiaries are called by "community engagement" requirements because finding work will help lift them out of poverty and thus improve their health.
But the judge did not buy this argument. Instead, he wrote, HHS does not consider whether the work These requirements would do anything to support the core task of the program, namely the medical care of the poor.
"While the plaintiffs and their friends claim that these proclaimed health benefits are not substantiated by substantive evidence, the court does not need to penetrate this thicket, but the secretary's analysis fails for a more fundamental reason, it's little more than a sleight of hands "wrote the judge.
"The message here? Anyone who wants to add work requirements" The bar is high to show that there is a connection to health, "says Rodney Whitlock, health policy analyst with Mintz Levin, a law firm with expertise in the healthcare industry Healthcare.
HHS has approved work requirements for Medicaid in four states. According to the Kaiser Family Foundation, another seven states have requests for regulatory approval.