A fertility doctor in Canada was officially reprimanded this week for inseminating at least 11 women with his own sperm and giving wrongful sperm to dozens of women since the 1970s.
Dr. The 80-year-old Norman Barwin was declared "incompetent" by the College of Physicians and Surgeons of Ontario, from which Barwin resigned in 2014, after patients complained that their children were conceived with semen that was not their intended father belonged. 19659002] Ontario College of Physicians and Surgeons stated that Barwin "committed an act of professional misconduct by failing to comply with the standard of practice" and "committed acts or omissions" that members reasonably considered " would be "disgraceful, dishonorable or unprofessional," the college said Thursday. "The Disciplinary Committee also noted that Barwin is incompetent. "
Allegations against Barwin date back to 1
In 2015, the daughter of one The patient, who used donor sperm, was curious about her genealogy and began research to discover that a second cousin of hers was a relative of Barwin.
Barwin confirmed by a DNA test that he was her father, but said, "the only time he used his own sperm was when he calibrated an automatic sperm counter", and part of it must have been confused with donor semen.
Another patient who had a daughter in 1990 The world brought and believed to be impregnated with her husband's sperm, later became suspicious when her daughter was diagnosed with celiac disease, a genetic her condition That's neither her nor her husband.
The two young women compared their DNA results and carried out further research to find that they were half-siblings, and Barwin was their father.
They have now identified nine other children who were conceived with Barwins sperm when he said he uses donor semen or semen from partners of his patients.
NBC News was unable to instantly reach a lawyer or other representative for Barwin.
The doctor is charged in 2016 The process of supplying another 50 to 100 women who were later born with the wrong sperm.
One family describes that they were traumatized when they found out that their two children were not full siblings, but half-siblings with different fathers.
] Another mother received incorrect information about her sperm donor and can not get any information about the medical history of her learning disabled son because she has no idea where the sperm came from.  Another woman found out that her children were related, but not to her husband, whose sperm she thought was in need.
"Whether Dr. Barwin's actions were accidental or intentional, the suffering he caused remains deep and far-reaching," Dr. Edward G. Hughes, an obstetrician / gynecologist, according to the Ontario College of Physicians and Surgeons.
He said that the full extent of the damage was unknown, as many women undergoing fertility services do not understand it. "For 51 children born with the wrong sperm heritage, maybe 100 could get the wrong sperm during their treatment," he said.
Hughes also said that the chamber could not be cleaned after it had been calibrated with his own semen probably it would not have led to a pregnancy of his semen.
"It would be remarkable if a single pregnancy had taken place in this way," he said. "Eleven pregnancies conceived in this way over two or more decades are neither statistically plausible nor credible."
"Offspring live an avoidable genetic separation from their fathers and have no access to their genetic heritage," Hughes continued. "The children, the Dr. Barwin himself has witnessed, are burdened in this and other even deeper ways. They know that their own DNA and those of their children and beyond will always be related to him and his actions.
Barwin has not practiced since 2014. His registration at the Ontario College of Physicians and Surgeons was revoked earlier this year he was fined $ 10,370.