قالب وردپرس درنا توس
Home / Entertainment / Film criticism of yesterday: What if the Beatles never existed?

Film criticism of yesterday: What if the Beatles never existed?



I Yesterday Richard Curtis, the failing musician Jack Malik (Himesh Patel), was knocked over by a bus during a mysterious global power outage and awakened from coma by Richard Curtis under the direction of Danny Boyle that he seems to be the only person in the world who remembers the Beatles. He soon decides to use the band's suddenly unknown songs to begin his career with predictably spectacular results.

Early in the movie, as he still settles for this new world, we see Jack rush into the B section of his vinyl collection, hurling albums to the floor as he searches in vain for the fabs. One of the records we can clearly see is Brothers by The Black Keys. Brothers was produced by Danger Mouse, who started his production career with The Gray Album a 2004 mash-up of The White Album with vocals from Jay-Zs The Black Album which itself was a reference to The White Album . No Beatles means no Gray Album does not mean an early breakthrough for Danger Mouse means no brothers .

In itself this could not be more trivial. I am well aware that only the smallest streak of Yesterday is known or important to the audience for the chronology of Danger Mouse's production career, but it is just one of countless loose threads that threaten to unravel the whole while pulling concept. The film is littered with references to artists and albums that emerged from the example of the Beatles. The Beach Boys made the giant leap of Pet Sounds because they "prayed for an album that would compete with Rubber Soul ". Neutral Milk Hotel emerged from Georgia's Beatles-crazy Elephant 6 collectively, Coldplay's "Fix You" is the blueprint of the secular gospel of "Hey Jew" and so on. There's only one band that disappears in this Fabs-free universe and makes for one of the movie's biggest laughs, but that just means Curtis and Boyle have made the fundamental mistake in their premise about the joke transparent. Obviously, the butterfly effect is another thing that has disappeared from Jack's timeline after the coma. "A world without the Beatles is a world that's infinitely worse," says a character in a movie that almost equals a world without the Beatles. The most popular songs of all time will be a huge hit and the standard answer to the complaints A music journalist says: Turn off your mind, relax and float downstream. I certainly would not have expected exposure levels to be lost. But mainstream entertainment is quite capable of revealing the darker, stranger implications of a gnarled premise. It's a wonderful life shows the wave effect when a man who thinks he's insignificant is taken out of the world. Back to the Future In Part II the future is about whether a schoolmob takes a sports almanac or not. Curtis' own About Time also tries to clarify how his version of time travel works. Yesterday however, makes a delectable suggestion, showing no interest in exploring it, and not in a spooky, dreamlike, mysterious way, like David Lynch. Not only does Curtis not answer the questions he has raised; He does not even seem to notice that he asked her. Nevertheless, it makes you think. I left the cinema to answer the two main questions the filmmakers wanted to skip. What would be the history of pop music without the Beatles? Second, would their songs be objective, without the context of the four men who recorded them, unquestionably fantastic?

Very few artists seem to be absolutely irreplaceable in retrospect. If Elvis Presley had been born dead instead of his twin Jesse, another charismatic white guy would have benefited from rock & # 39; s roll. If Kraftwerk had all been killed in a tragic highway accident in 1

972, someone else would have exhausted the potential of synthesizers. Pop's progress would certainly have been different, but these vacancies would have been filled in one way or another. However, the Beatles have created their own place. Rob Sheffield writes in his wonderful book Dreaming The Beatles : "The Beatles have invented most of what rock stars do. They invented the separation. They invented drugs. They invented long hair, went to India, had a guru, round glasses, solo careers, beards, press conferences, divorcing girlfriends, wrote their own songs, funny drummers. They invented the idea of ​​putting together a global mass audience and then challenging, disappointing and confusing that audience. As for the rest of the planet, they invented England. [Sheffield writes with his tongue on his cheek, but he means some of these things quite seriously and correctly.] In the same sense, you might well concept albums, bizarre alter egos, psychedelia, pandandom, vanity record labels, autonostalgia, homoeroticism, the quadrangular It's impossible to overestimate the impact of the Beatles on the form and size of pop music – even people who hate the Beatles know what the main reason is, why they hate them Make exaggerations a matter of course. "At this point, Rock'n'Roll is famous because it's what the Beatles did," writes Sheffield, "just as the theater is famous for its pieces are what Shakespeare wrote. "It's a reasonable analogy. In Yesterday the Beatles Channeling Jack is referred to as the" Shakespeare of pop music. "

If You Career n the artists mentioned in Yesterday whether it is The Rolling Stones, David Bowie or the film's lovable Costar Ed Sheeran, their long and winding paths lead back to The Beatles, the band that led to the First time countless things made possible. Mick Jagger said that the Stones were content to be blues purists until they heard "Love Me Do," and then spent the six years until Beggar's Banquet did what the Beatles had just done , only with a mockery. Bowie producer Tony Visconti said in the sixties, "In the shadow of the Beatles, it was difficult to come up with an original idea."

There are other kick-down-the-door artists whose absence complicates many later developments Imagine – Bob Dylan, James Brown – but not many and none whose influence has penetrated so deeply into the foundation of our common popular culture. I could imagine how the Beatles were wiped out with the incredible power of Thanos' finger snap: half (at least) of pop music since 1963 would just disappear. Yesterday: Infinity War .


Curtis' screenplay pays more attention to my second question: would the Beatles songs be irresistible, even if they were detached from John, Paul, George, and Ringo? Jack's success depends on this being the case, but the answer is not obvious, as there is a difference between songs and records. A great song retains its size even though it is played by an amateur on an acoustic guitar, whereas a great record depends on a particular voice, arrangement, production, and personality. Take Prince. "Purple Rain" is robust enough to be translatable, but Kiss without Prince leaves most listeners at a loss. Most of Bruce Springsteen's hits are versatile songs, while most of Madonnas are primarily records: you do not hear many Buskers playing "Vogue".

Yesterday suggests the fascinating possibility that the Beatles songs would not be life altering without the larger-than-life characters, but Curtis resists this provocative idea just to turn away. Jack does not succeed immediately, until he suddenly finds it, and that option disappears. Of course, these songs are ice-cold classics that would make no one the most famous songwriter in the world. Those who impress the people in the film are the ones who learn kids at school: "Yesterday," "Let It Be," "Here Comes The Sun." Neither "Tomorrow Never Knows," in which George Martin and Geoff Emerick helped The Beatles transform the studio into an instrument, nor "I Am the Walrus," which played with the listener's investment in the Beatles myth, nor "A Day In The Life, "which did both, in the scene where Jack is alone with his guitar and tries to remember the Beatles songbook, he writes the titles on post-it notes and sticks them to his bedroom wall One of them is "Revolution 9", The White Album the famous avant-garde audio collage, I would have liked to hear how Jack tried to recreate that with six strings.

Even some of the more immediate songs of The Beatles "The Long And Winding Road," played by Jack, is uniquely beautiful, but is performed by The Beatles in Let It Be (19459006), the swan song they sing a month after the Separation published. It was a heartbreaking coda for the most compelling narrative in pop history. Turning to the other end of the career, I suspect that "I want to hold your hand" in 2019 would sound surprisingly bleak, and "I saw her standing there" ("She was only 17, you know what I mean") a few problems cause a problem, but they work like gangbusters for Jack. How easy the music industry would be in real life if a song was just a song and nothing else mattered.


The flattening of chronology and context obscured the fact that many of the Beatles' greatest successes were only possible because they were the shitty Beatles! This fact is only briefly acknowledged in Yesterday when Jack's record label boss tells him that his proposed album title, Sgt Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band "becomes too confusing" and "too confusing "Is" many words ". That's believable. Only the biggest band in the world could have got away with such an eccentric idea. But later we learn that Jack is "Being For The Benefit Of Mr Kite!" Play what would be unbearable in the universe of the movie. In this way, the script regularly makes one step forward and two steps back. There's another glimpse of the label marketing Jack as a lonely genius in a world of samples and songwriting camps and crumpling him up, crushing alone. Paul and Ringo often say that they pity Elvis, that they had to deal with fame with one hand because they would have gone crazy without their friends. That makes "help!" the only one of Jack's performances that exceeds karaoke. Tailored as a ragged, desperate punk rock howl, it's a tiny crack in the cozy bubble of good humor in the movie that's quickly sealed. The fact that Yesterday is more of a concern for a boy and a child It is unlikely that a girl (like the Beatles) who explains or explores his premise will hold her back. Warm, solemn and outrageously obvious, it is the cinematic equivalent of the "na na na" coda of "Hey Jude". But it made me fantasize about a Black Mirror -style anthology series in which half a dozen authors got the same basic idea and were asked to pursue the implications of a Beatleless world without having to worry about it whether Himesh Patel gets her along with Lily James. This line, which I quoted earlier, would make an excellent writing exercise: "A world without the Beatles is a world that is infinitely worse."

Read now:

The hippest moments of the Beatles

Catch-22 is an experiment by George Clooney that is largely successful

The best, strangest and most beautiful moments in Glastonbury as told by the people who lived it


Source link