Following a question on Twitter about how SpaceX wants to create the really massive lattice ribs for Starship's Super Heavy Booster, CEO Elon Musk announced that SpaceX will manufacture them from welded steel in the early years.
SpaceX built aluminum lattice fins for the recovery of the Falcon 9 and Falcon Heavy boosters, which were used to maneuver the rockets at high speeds. At Falcon 9 Block 5, aluminum louvres were completely eliminated in favor of larger titanium lamellas, necessitated by exceptionally rapid reentry that would have melted almost through the aluminum fins on several occasions. Now, SpaceX plans to switch to steel fins for its next-generation Starship launchers.
̵1; Elon Musk (@elonmusk) October 3, 2019
In response to Twitter When asked by the user, Musk merely stated that Super Heavy's wire ribs were made of "welded steel". would be made, which certainly corresponds to the meanwhile known love of the CEO for the material. Finally, in October 2018, Musk managed to convince most senior engineers who reported to him that despite years of work and extensive testing, SpaceX required a radical redesign of Starship.
Prior to this radical change, SpaceX had spent at least 2-3 years developing a spaceship (formerly Big F_____ Spaceship, BFS) made almost entirely of carbon fiber composites, an extremely lightweight material that can be optimized for high altitudes strength. Carbon fiber composite materials are undoubtedly light and strong (optimal for aerospace), but have a very low heat tolerance and can react violently with supercooled liquid oxygen, as Musk concludes in late 2018. Almost all of Falcon 9's aluminum alloys have similarly low melting points, and they also face the challenges of material selection, which has been made significantly more difficult by the need to regain and reuse orbital stages of the orbital class.
Musk finally decided that this is the case The redesign of Starship with steel (alloys with especially high melting points and good strength) was the right way. According to Musk, the high-quality carbon fiber composites pursued by SpaceX originally cost about $ 130,000 per tonne, resulting in a truly incredible price of $ 400 million – $ 500 million or more only . to buy the materials needed to build a single spaceship and a super heavy booster. Steel, on the other hand, is literally 50 times cheaper, costing SpaceX about $ 2,500 per ton, or just $ 10 million in structural stock for each ship / booster pair.
Stainless Steel Man
CEO Elon Musk spoke at a presentation on September 28 about the Starship stand in 2019 and could not praise his decision to upgrade to stainless steel Best design decision he has ever made. It remains to be seen if the eccentric autodidact engineer's decision was the right one, but the progress SpaceX has made in just 10 to 11 months is undeniable. SpaceX moved from a nearly empty shale to Starhopper's 150m test flight in about 6 months and from Starship Mk1 in about 6 months.
According to Musk, the properties of stainless steel – mainly a high melting point / working temperature and a tendency to strengthen at cryogenic temperatures – mean that the relatively heavy material is capable of producing a launch vehicle that could someday Far lighter and more efficient than carbon composites (BFR) or aluminum alloys (Falcon 9). These properties make Starship / Super Heavy much stronger when filled with cold propellant, and require little or no external heat shield on the half, while a reusable Al / composite rocket requires high thermal protection on almost all exposed surfaces.
In the effort to remove all the ultra-expensive, non-essential materials from the Removing constructions from Starship and Super Heavy, Musk also seems to have his eyes on the grid fins of the booster. As described earlier in this article, SpaceX replaced the aluminum louvres of Falcon 9 with titanium lamellas, which required the company to produce the world's largest one-piece titanium casting. Musk has repeatedly pointed out that each grid fin is extremely expensive.
Given their cost, Musk (or SpaceX) has apparently decided that future (larger?) SpaceX missiles will try to avoid large titanium rockets castings. Even so, Super Heavy still needs massive grid fins: The official renderings released last month by SpaceX revealed a new diamond shape for the booster's fins, and Musk later went to Twitter to betray that instead they made of welded steel would consist of titanium.
Based on SpaceX's official 2019 Super Heavy render, the booster's lattice ribs measure approximately 7 x 3 m (23 x 10 ft), with the titanium ribs of the Falcon 9 (perhaps 2 x 1.2 m) rated 8 The surface can be overshadowed by 10 m. 301 series stainless steel has a melting point and heat capacity that is about 15% lower than that of grade 5 titanium. However, its strength properties are otherwise similar and remain mechanically functional at almost three times the working temperature of titanium (840 ° C vs. 330 ° C).
Above all, 301 steel is not only about 15 to 20 times cheaper than titanium, but the process of producing large steel parts – especially by welding instead of casting – is dramatically faster, easier and cheaper than using Titan to work and shape it. With their reasonably similar properties and increased size of Super Heavy, it is likely that steel lattice fins will show little or no ablation even in the hottest atmospheric reentry, and it would still be extremely easy and inexpensive to either repair or replace fins in the unlikely event claim.
Considering how quickly and relatively simply SpaceX built true-to-scale flight hardware out of steel and assumes that there are no technical obstacles due to scale changes, that would not be in the least surprising SpaceX manufactures and tests in welded steel louvre blades on Falcon 9 boosters in the near future
Teslarati newsletters provide up-to-date information, on-site perspectives, and unique insights into SpaceX's rocket launch and recovery processes ].