What happened at the second hearing on Tuesday?
- Kurt Volker, former Special Representative for Ukraine, said he was unaware that efforts were under way to pressure Ukraine to initiate investigations. Volker said along with Tim Morrison, a former National Security Council official, who Worried about a leak in the summary of the call of the President of July 25 with the President of Ukraine.
- Read and look at the highlights at the first hearing here.
- Download the free CBS News app to stream live coverage of all impeachment hearings The Ukrainian government aimed to launch anti-corruption investigations against former Vice President Joe Biden and his son Hunter, but said he had Objection raised if he had known then what he now knows. 1
"In retrospect, I understand that others considered the idea of investigating possible corruption involving Burisma as equivalent to that of former Vice President Biden," Volker said, referring to the energy company Hunter Biden had shut down. "I found them to be very different – the former as appropriate and inconspicuous, the latter unacceptable – looking back, I should have seen this connection differently, and had I done so, I would have raised my own objections."
Volker is one of the key players in the effort to use the prospect of visiting the White House as a lever against the Ukrainian government. Morrison received a phone call between President Trump and Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky on July 25, and told the committee in a nonpublic will that he did not believe "anything illegal was being discussed."
Volker also defended Biden against allegations he did not properly do. He called him "an honorable man" and dismissed the allegations as "untrustworthy."
"At no time did I realize that I wanted to press Ukraine to investigate former Vice President Biden," Volker said.
Morrison, in turn, said he was not worried about anything he heard on the July 25 call he heard first-hand. However, he was increasingly concerned about a delay in US military aid to Ukraine and said US Ambassador Gordon Sondland had spoken directly and regularly to the President. Sondland told Ukrainian officials that the delay in military aid was "likely" to be dependent on the initiation of an investigation.
Schiff starts a hearing that Nunes calls the "circus".
15:37 pm: Schiff began his opening speech with a summary of many events leading up to that day, describing the participation of Volker and Morrison. Republicans demanded the testimony of these two officials. Schiff declined to agree to a series of Republican requests for more witnesses, including Hunter Biden. "I appreciate the minority's request for these two important witnesses," Schiff said.
Nunes said the hearing was "Act Two of Today's Circus," according to Tuesday morning's testimony.
The Supreme Republican on the committee has rejected the Democrats' decision not to testify to Hunter Biden.
and Nunes have both made new statements for each new hearing – Kathryn Watson
Morrison says his fears of disclosing a phone call have been "realized"
Volker that he has worked through the "official channel" for Ukraine policy [Day3Part11:KurtVolker'sopeningspeech
15:45: ] People He vigorously defended himself in his prepared opening speech and denied that he, US Ambassador to the EU, Gordon Sondland, and Energy Secretary Rick Perry had formed a separate "irregular" channel to inform Ukrainian politics. "Volker, who has a long career in foreign service, also denied that he had any knowledge of Mr. Trump, who asked Ukraine to investigate the bidens."
"At no time was I aware or knowingly involved On an attempt to urge Ukraine to investigate the former Vice President Biden, "Volker said, adding that his role is" not an irregular channel, but the official channel. "
Volker expressed concern that the ongoing Talk about Ukraine has influenced American efforts in Ukraine and said, "It is a tragedy for the United States and Ukraine that our efforts in this area, which have borne fruit, are now in disarray. "
Volker said he had linked Zelensky 's advisor Andriy Yermak with Rudy Giuliani to convince Giuliani of the Ukrainian government, not against Mr. Trump, saying that he had never called Giuliani" speech in the name of Volker interviewed Yermak in August about a statement that Zelensky would make to say that Ukraine would initiate investigations into the decree, mentioning neither Burisma nor the Biden, Volker said he knew at the time The publication of a statement does not disclose any link between the safety stop and the making of a statement.
Eventually, Volker said he had never used the term "three amigos" and added, "I'm very shocked when I hear it." He also said he did not know about a call between Sondland and Mr. Trump on July 26. – Grace Seger's
Volker said he knew nothing of a collaboration Hang Between Military Assistance and Investigations
4:04 pm: Volker said he knows nothing about a delay in US military aid to Ukraine and the country, which is forging ahead with investigations.
I opposed the US Security Assistance attitude when I learned about it on July 18 and thought we could turn it around before the Ukrainians ever knew or were alerted, "Volker said he considered the delay "as a US political problem that we had to fix internally."
Volker said he had discussed the delay with the Ukrainians in late August after Politico had reported that the aid was being deferred.
Instead of telling them that they need to do something to release the hold, I told them the opposite – you should not be worried, it was an internal US problem, and it was us working on fixing it. " He said, "I did not know that others were going to deliver another message to them at the same time." – Stefan Becket
Volker said he sees Joe Biden's involvement in Ukraine and the work of Hunter Biden as "separate" questions.
16:10 pm: Vessel asked Volker about former Ukrainian Prosecutor Yuriy Lutsenko. Volker voiced concerns over the credibility of the former public prosecutor, who unjustly polluted former US Ambassador Marie Yovanovitch. Volker said he and others have strong faith in the integrity of Yovanovitch.
Volker also expressed his confidence in the integrity of former Vice President Joe Biden and called him an "honorable man". He said he views Hunter Biden's involvement in Burisma's board as a separate matter.
"I think they were separated," Volker said. – Kathryn Watson
Volker has raised objections to Joe Biden's investigation.
16:16: Volker has announced this has "objected" to Ukraine and initiated an investigation by former Vice President Joe Biden. He said he did not realize that Mr. Trump had the invitation to investigate Burisma as well as the request to investigate Biden until July 25.
"I find the allegations against Vice President Biden selfish and untrustworthy," Volker said. Volker reiterated that he considered the investigation of Burisma and Biden to be separate, but in hindsight he understood how Ukrainian officials could be confused. – Grace Segers
Volker now says the investigation came on July 10th.
16:19 pm: In his statement in camera, Volker said "investigations" had not been discussed at a disputed meeting between US and Ukrainian officials on July 10, which raised the issue of whether they have answered, answered "no".
In his opening speech on Tuesday, Volker revised this report and said that it had been collected to confirm the accounts of other participants.
"As I recall, the meeting was essentially over when Ambassador Sondland made a general comment on the investigation," Volker said in his statement, referring to Gordon Sondland, the US Ambassador to the EU. "I think we all considered it inappropriate, the conversation did not continue and the meeting ended." – Stefan Becket
Morrison says the caller overview has been accidentally moved to the secure server.
4:30 pm: Morrison immediately reported his concern about the July 25 phone call to the NSC lawyer and access to the call log was to be restricted.
Morrison said he was not worried about the content of the call but feared that there would be "political consequences" if more people had access to the call history. Morrison said NSC's legal advisor, John Eisenberg, later told him that the call was on a high-security server that, according to Eisenberg, was the result of a "management error" and a "mistake."
"Have you ever asked the Legal Adviser of NSC? Advisers to restrict access before?" Democratic lawyer Daniel Goldman asked.
"No," said Morrison. – Grace Segers
Volker said Zelensky believed Trump had misunderstood him.
16:34 pm: Volker testified that a meeting of the White House with Zelensky and Mr. Trump was so critical because Zelensky's Mr. Trump misunderstood him. According to Volker, Mr. Trump seemed to have a negative impression of the people working around Zelensky.
But Zelensky, Volker said, was interested in eradicating corruption and wanted to make sure Mr. Trump saw it.
Also popular was Zelensky, who received 73% of the votes. Nevertheless, Zelensky knew that his image in Ukraine would be strengthened by the images of a meeting between him and Mr. Trump. – Kathryn Watson
Volker says investigations have been "helpful" to secure the meeting.
16:44 pm: Volker testified that he did not believe that a statement announcing the investigation was a condition for a meeting at the White House, but said he found it "helpful "to plan a meeting.
"If we did not have a statement, I would not give up and think:" Oh, we "I'll never have a meeting," said Volker.
An explanation was never made, and Zelensky did White house not visited yet – Grace Segers
Nunes calls the Democrats 'strategy "drug trafficking"
16:59 pm: Nunes Begins The 45-minute majority poll said he has "bad news" for the witnesses – the TV ratings are "low down" for the hearing, which, he said, should not be taken personally.
"What Whatever the Democrats think, the Americans do not buy, "Nunes said, before handing it over to the Republican lawyer.
" Drug "is the same term the former national security adviser John Bolton used to refer to the thrust too describe how to get Ukraine to investigate the biden. – Kathryn Watson
Volker said he sees nothing unusual in keeping relief supplies.
17:02: Volker testified that he does not find it unusual that the administration has imposed a ban on Ukraine's support.
"I just assumed that this is part of the decision-making process," Volker said, adding that he had found backlogs from aid in previous administrations. He also said that he thought the fortress had to do with the fear that Zelensky would not be a reformer.
He also stated that Trump considers Ukraine "strongly negative", but said that the president's skepticism about Ukraine is reasonable. History of corruption. – Grace Segers
Volker: "I was never involved in anything I consider to be a bribe"
17:27 : Steve Castor, the Republican lawyer, asked Volker if he was involved in any consideration or bribe. Recently, some Democrats, including spokeswoman Nancy Pelosi, have called Mr. Trump's request for a bid investigation "bribery".
"I was never involved in anything that I think is bribery." Said Volker. "Or blackmail," he added at Castor's request. – Grace Segers
Morrison says he heard nothing that worried him on July 25.
17:33 pm: Morrison, asked by the Republican lawyer if he has heard of it. This comment is certainly repeated by the Republicans to prove that Zelensky's president's demand was not wrong. He also said he considered the summary of the solicitation published by the White House to be complete and correct. However, Morrison also expressed concerns that National Security Council legal representatives were not present at the request, and feared the call would expire. – Kathryn Watson
Morrison Discusses Concern over Vindmans Judgment
17:35 pm: Republican lawyer Steve Castor asked Morrison for concern within the NSC over the verdict of Alexander Vindman. He asked Morrison about concerns his predecessor, Fiona Hill, may have had, but Morrison's lawyer said the question was beyond his scope.
Morrison referred to his earlier testimony, in which he said others might have voiced concerns about Vindman leakage of information, which Vindman denied earlier in the day.
Morrison also said he was surprised that Vindman had not come to him on concerns about the July 25 phone call, but had turned directly to NSC's lawyer.
"If" Morrison, Vindman's supervisor, said he was concerned about the content of the call. That's what I expected to be notified. "In his Tuesday morning testimony, Vindman said that former National Security Advisor John Bolton – Morrison's superior – had told him to address his concerns directly to the Legal Counsel of NSC.
Morrison also stated that Vindman was frustrated by his disappointment at the time and was excluded from some important meetings related to Ukraine's policy – Grace Seger's
ship adds another 30 minutes of staffing
18:03 pm: After a pause, Schiff embarked on two more 15-minute sessions, which were controlled by him and Nunes, before moving on to membership questions .- Rebecca Kaplan
Morrison discusses "the Gordon problem"  18:16: Morrison said he had not always followed the suggestions of Sondland, saying his predecessor, Fiona Hill, had Sondlands Rol in the design of Ukraine policy as "the Gordon problem".
"I have not always responded to the things Gordon suggested," Morrison said. Several witnesses have now stated that Sondland has played an excessive role in shaping Ukraine's policy.
Sondland witnesses to the committee on Wednesday. – Grace Segers
Volker says that at a meeting on 10 July, Sondland made inquiries that this was an "Eyeroll moment".
18:28: Volker spoke about his participation in a meeting with the Ukrainian on July 10, officials whom he initially did not remember in his previous testimony. Volker said that Sondland has initiated "investigations" with the Ukrainian officials, which then led former national security adviser John Bolton to cancel the meeting.
"I thought it was a feast for the eyes," Volker said. "It was not the time or the place to speak." – Grace Segers
GOP congressman questions credibility of intelligence agencies
19:12: Republican Congressman Brad Wenstrup criticized the intelligence services and questioned the generally accepted conclusion of US intelligence that Russia and not Russia Ukraine interfered in the 2016 elections.
Wenstrup said that members of the intelligence community are some of the same individuals involved in the "Russia collusion fraud" in connection with the investigation of the Special Representative.
Wenstrup also compared Giuliani's role in shaping Ukraine's policy is that of former basketball player Dennis Rodman in North Korea. Rodman, however, had no close personal relationship with the president like Giuliani. – Grace Segers
Volker admits that he did not solve the "Giuliani problem".
19:26: Volker testified that he had tried to work with Giuliani to convince him, and thus the president, that the new Ukrainian president was not corrupt. However, he said the July 25 phone call had made it clear to him that Giuliani and the president still believed that Ukraine needed to investigate Burisma and the Bidens.
"That's right," said Volker. – Grace Segers
Trump weighs in hearings and calls it a "great day for Republicans."
8:11 pm: When the final legislators polled Volker and Morrison at the impeachment hearings, Mr. Trump intervened in the case and said it was a "great day for Republicans."
A great day for Republicans, a great day for our country!
– Donald J. Trump (@realDonaldTrump) November 20, 2019
On Tuesday, Mr. Trump said he saw part of the first hearing and that Republicans "killed" him. "- Grace Segers