قالب وردپرس درنا توس
Home / World / Trump makes 13 false claims in the Cabinet meeting

Trump makes 13 false claims in the Cabinet meeting

"And why not, why should Honduras or Guatemala or El Salvador – why should they keep their criminals if they put them in a caravan, lose them in a caravan and send them to the United States?" he said. "We all take because the Democrats do not allow immigration laws that mean anything, it's terrible."

Facts First: Although the Department of Homeland Security said that some members of recent caravan migrants had done this criminal past there is simply no evidence that the governments of Honduras, Guatemala or El Salvador deliberately put criminals in the caravans to impose them on the United States who decide for themselves that they want to migrate. There was no indication that governments forced someone into one of the caravan groups.

"Everything we've seen suggests that the caravan migrants were loosely organized and largely spontaneous and not organized or led by the governments of El Salvador, Guatemala or Honduras," said Ariel Ruiz, an associate political analyst at the Institute for Migration Policy.

Migrants and Courts

Trump repeated one of his frequent false claims about migrants being arrested and then released to await a trial.

"We catch them and release them, we catch them and say, 'Come back to court in five years', and nobody comes back Be careful, I want to be precise because I do not want the press to say 'I'm inaccurate' Two percent come back And these people wonder why ̵

1; why are they coming back? They're the only ones. "

Facts first: Trump was not nearly accurate. 89 percent of asylum seekers have appeared in court to obtain a ruling on their case in the 2017 financial year according to the government ; it was 72% for all types of migrants.

It is possible that the percentage has dropped since 2017, but there is no indication that it has fallen to nearly 2% or zero.


Trump also repeated one of his regular false claims about how trafficking can not be carried out through legal ports of entry.

"We are doing very well, but we have no help at all from the Democrats, they obviously have nothing against crime, drugs and human trafficking, which is a huge problem, and it's mostly about trafficking in women. with their big, wonderful hearts, trafficking in women, where three, four, five women sit in the back of a van or in a car and cross areas where there will soon be a wall, but at present there is no wall, because you obviously can not come through the ports of entry, "Trump said

Facts first: In fact, many victims of trafficking come via entry ports, according to experts for trafficking and according to international data . Experts believe that victims are more likely to be fooled into crossing the border than being abducted and being stuck in a vehicle.

"I've been dealing with human trafficking across multiple continents in several countries for more than two decades. In all the work I've done with victims of human trafficking, I've met someone who was actually kidnapped and thrown into a car," Martina Vandenberg from the Human Trafficking Legal Center told CNN in January, when Trump shared frequent stories about women being tied up and gagged in cars.

According to experts, many victims are tempted to come to the United States with the promise of good work. Others are forced by threats against their families or themselves. While experts argue that there may be some cases like those described by Trump, they emphasize that such cases are in a small minority.

In 2018, the United Nations International Organization for Migration stated that "in the past 10 years, nearly 80% of travel undertaken by victims who have been internationally trafficked passes through official border points such as airports and land border checkpoints." [19659017] Democrats and Borders

"We are very well Well, but we do not have any help from the Democrats – on the contrary, they want open borders – they obviously have nothing against crime, drugs and human trafficking, which is a huge problem, "said Trump.

Facts First: [19659003] Some Democrats, including presidential candidates such as Elizabeth Warren and Julián Castro have advocated a substantial easing of immigration laws, including a decriminalization of the law on the illegal crossing of the border.

But none of them has suggested opening the border literally for unrestricted migration.

LNG plant in Louisiana

Trump also advocated an energy facility that he is not responsible for.

"Or LNG facilities, I've just left Louisiana to cut a $ 10 billion LNG facility that is so incredible that people would not believe it – it took many, many Years to get permits, they could not get the permits, but we got the permits and we got them very quickly. "

Facts First: The permits for the visited Establishment Trump were granted by the Obama administration. [19659025] Trump spoke at the Cameron Liquefied Natural Gas Export Plant of Sempra Energy in Louisiana in May. The company says on its website: "The Federal Energy Regulatory Commission approved the project in June 2014." The company confirmed FactCheck.org: "You're right, Cameron LNG was approved in 2014."

The first delivery of the system took place at the end of May.

North Korea and the US remain

] A program to rescue the remains of US soldiers who died during the Korean War in North Korea has been suspended. Trump continued to insist that it last.
"We got our hostages back (from North Korea), we got the remains back and they keep coming," he said.
Facts First: Although North Korea returned some remains last year, this is no longer the case. The US military announced in May that the remainder of the program was suspended for the remainder of the 2019 fiscal year, as North Korea ceased communications with the US state agency.
Trump could announce the return of mortal remains in the past tense: North Korea returned 55 cases of potential mortal remains in the summer of 2018. At the end of May, six soldiers from these cases were identified.
But the remains are not returned. The Pentagon's POW / MIA accounting agency announced in May that no remnants will come back this fiscal year. The agency said North Korea has not talked to the agency at all since the Hanoi summit in February between Trump and Kim Jong Un, which ended abruptly.

Automobile Trade

"And every car that goes through this was once made in the US – now Mexico has 30% of our car business, but that will not happen anymore, there will be no more companies because we have it. " Reasons they can not leave anymore. There's simply no reason for them to leave, "said Trump.

Facts First: Nothing in Trump's revised trade agreement with Mexico and Canada prevents the auto industry from joining companies from the United States

New rules are set to help convince them to produce in North America in general and in the US in particular.

The Border Wall

"We're building a lot of walls right now," said Trump.

Facts First: There have not been any new miles of walls built since then. [19659006] Customs and Border Guards announced in a leaflet that "construction works" had begun for about 21 miles of the new barrier wall system and dam wall system in the Rio Grande Valley, but such "activities" are different from the construction itself; The cutting down of plants, as previously told us by a customs and border protection spokesman, and there is currently no evidence that construction of the actual wall started. Even though it started quietly now, that's not a lot of wall.

Trump said this spring that replacement fences should be counted by the media as his "wall" as he replaces ineffective old barriers with effective modern ones. This is subjective, but we consider it appropriate to focus on the new obstacles he promised during his campaign.

Women's Unemployment

Trump bragged precisely with the record unemployment rate for members

"Our unemployment figures are historical in the sense that we never had better numbers … women, 75 years, "he said.

] Facts first: Trump could have rounded, but he was a bit off the mark. The female unemployment rate for June was 3.6%, a tad above the 3.4% in April and 3.5% in May.
It's been 66 years since the women's rate was so low, not 75 years.

Tariffs on China

Trump returned to a favorite A story about how he decided to announce $ 16 billion in development aid to farmers through his tariff fight were injured with China.

"From customs duties, I took $ 16 billion to make up for the deficit." I went to (agriculture) secretary Sonny Perdue … I said, "What was the highest amount China made in the form of a purchase "16 billion dollars." "I said that's fine, we're taking multiple times the tariffs, we're going to help the farmers, and I did that with $ 16 billion," Trump said.

Facts First: $ 16 Billion This is not the sum that China has ever spent on US agricultural products in a year. According to government figures, China spent $ 29.6 billion in 2014 .
The New York Times reported Monday that Trump's tariffs for China have so far generated about $ 21 billion, which is not "many, many" is "$ 16 billion." And economic studies have shown that the Americans, not people or companies in China, bear the bulk of the costs.

Trade deficit with China

"During the Obama administration, $ 500 billion was raised annually China lost. Five Hundred Billion, "said Trump.

Facts First: The US never had an annual trade deficit of $ 500 billion with China (Trump calls trade deficits losses, most economists do not.) The deficit of Goods and services in 2018 was $ 381 billion and it was $ 420 billion if only goods were counted and services excluded, which was a record number. "Chinese Economy Since Trump's election He said," China has lost $ 20 trillion "

Facts First: There is no obvious basis for the $ 20 trillion dollar figure, and experts on the Chinese economy have rejected even Trump's earlier allegations that China's wealth is $ 10 trillion

We reviewed one of those $ 10 trillion claims for the Toronto Star in May, we wrote then: "George Magnus, a research associate at the China Center of Oxford University, said: & # 39; I can not really summarize these numbers to anything that I know. & # 39; Magnus found that the total market capitalization of the Shanghai index at that time was just over $ 5 trillion. Derek Scissors, an expert on US economic relations with Asia at the conservative think tank of the American Enterprise Institute, also said China's fortune has fallen $ 10 trillion, & # 39; is not in evidence. & # 39; "

The Iran Deal

" Remember one thing. An agreement was reached with then-Secretary of State Kerry and with President Obama. This agreement was a billion-dollar disaster, "he said.

Facts first: The US has not" donated "tens of billions to complete Iran's nuclear deal, which allowed Iran access tens of billions of his own assets – not on US cash – that had been frozen in foreign financial institutions due to sanctions, according to experts, the total was well below $ 150 billion.

Trump has the 150 billion Dollar figure not invented from scratch: Obama himself has reflected in a 2015 interview that Iran has "parked $ 150 billion out of the country." However, experts in Iran and the Obama administration said that The amount of assets actually made available to Iran by the agreement is much lower.
In 2015, Secretary of State Jack Lew put the figure at 56 Billions of dollars. PolitiFact reported that Garbis Iradian, chief economist at the Institute of International Finance, had estimated it to be about $ 60 billion, and that Nader Habibi, professor of Middle Eastern economics at Brandeis University, said it was 25 to 50 years old Billions of dollars held dispute with representatives of the Iranian central bank.
Adam Szubin, a high-ranking Treasury Department official, testified before Congress in 2015 that "usable cash" would be "just over $ 50 billion." The remainder of Iran's overseas assets are either tied to "illiquid" projects "that can not be quickly or monetized, or consist of outstanding loans to Iranian companies that they can not repay."
As Trump The Obama administration routinely sent $ 1.7 billion to Iran to settle a decade-long dispute over the purchase of US military goods that Iran was plotting to overthrow its government in the 1979 Islamic Revolution. The goods were not delivered, and the US paid Iran its money back plus interest.

Other claims

Trump quoted two quotes for which there is no evidence. In the first case there is no indication that the quote itself was ever pronounced. The second case, in relation to Google and China, is about the substance of the quote.

Trump the hostage negotiator

"Our ambassador for hostage bargaining, Trump said, is the greatest of all times, I'm just telling you because you'll never say it." , he said.

Facts first: There is no public evidence for this quote.

The White House informed CBS that the quote originated from Robert C. O'Brien, Special Envoy of the President for Hostage Taking in the State Department. But nobody could find a record in which he said it.

It is of course possible that O & Brien Trump told this privately.


Trump was asked this morning for a tweet in which he cited a charge against Google of billionaire technology investor Peter Thiel in a speech this weekend assumed that Google may have made a "seemingly treacherous decision to cooperate with the Chinese military."

"He (Peter Thiel) made a very strong case," Trump said. "He's one of the top experts, maybe the top expert in all of these things, and he made a very big statement about Google, and it's a big statement to say that Google is not involved in a single country with China . " very positive for our country, "said Trump.

Facts First: Thiel, a board member on Facebook, did not provide evidence for his allegations on Fox News in either the Sunday speech or his Monday show has rejected the allegation: "As we said earlier, we are not working with the Chinese military," Google told CNN on Tuesday.

In March, Marine Corps General Joseph Dunford, chairman of Joint Chiefs of Staff told the Senate Committee on Armed Forces that Google's work in China "indirectly benefits the Chinese military."

In an interview with Fox Business on Monday, National Business Council Director Larry Kudlow said he had not spoken to Thiel and was " not "sure where he wanted to go or what he shows."

"I meet with Google's CEO on a regular basis, I think they work for Ameri ka, for our military and not for China, "Kudlow said.

Kevin Liptak of CNN contributed to this report.

Source link